When Patients Ask About Trail Running Shoes

Jenny L Sanders DPM

Giving patients guidance on trail running shoes can be a challenge as the design of these shoes is different from non-trail running shoes. Essentially, trail running shoes have a more rugged outsole of varying degrees to facilitate better grip of uneven terrain. They are also lower to the ground and softer for better shock absorption.

The problem is all the research and development goes into running shoes so you do not have the same choices with trail running shoes as you do with regular running shoes. Whereas a manufacturer may offer 10 different styles of regular running shoes, it may only offer two or three trail running styles. Also, when it comes to the trail running styles offered, they usually do not come in widths. Another problem with trail running shoes is that they typically are not what podiatrists consider stable as most lack a firm heel counter and are not torsionally stable.

Due to these differences, your runners may experience more injuries with trail running shoes than non-trail running shoes so it is important to educate them as to the differences.

It is also fine to recommend patients run trails in their non-trail running shoes, especially if their runs include both or shorter trail run distances.

Comments

Dr. Sanders, I've read most of your shoe recommendations/comments. I appreciate
and generally pass on your thoughts. But I take exception to the "Trail Running
Shoes" blog.

I hope but don't know if you've read the book 'Born to Run' by McDougall. His facts, commentary and observations of a heretofor 'unknown' tribe of Mexican runners sheds a whole new light on all of our ingrained running beliefs, especially with regard to
1) incidence of running injuries has NOT declined with years of improvements in shoes
2) ultra marathoners often run on trails, thus uneven surfaces, and the Tarahumara (sp)
do much better with a minimal shoe or even NO shoe than their shod counterparts.

The reasoning is that the foot must continually ADAPT to the terrain. In fact, it is 'DESIGNED'
to adapt, thanks to its multiple joints and axes. Thus, a 'firm heel counter and torsionally
stable' shank would more likely PRECLUDE AN INJURY.

The book, more importantly the rationale and analysis, which our profession understands and originated in biomechanics, has made a significant impact on my management of runners. By the way, most of the serious runners out there have read 'Born to Run' and look to us for thoughtful commentary.

I look forward to your response. Thanks in advance.

Add new comment