Prophylactic Foot Surgery In Patients With Diabetes: Is It Worth The Risk?
- Volume 21 - Issue 8 - August 2008
- 13007 reads
- 0 comments
In one study, researchers found that the TAL procedure reduced the ulcer recurrence rate by 75 percent at seven months and 52 percent at two years in comparison to conservative treatment.11 Flexor tenotomies for clawtoe deformity yielded favorable results in healing and preventing the recurrence of distal ulcers.9,10
In a randomized controlled study of non-infected neuropathic ulcers, surgical intervention reduced the re-ulceration rate to 14 percent whereas conservative treatment resulted in a re-ulceration rate of 42 percent at the six-month follow-up.12 In a study by Armstrong, et al., digital arthroplasty procedures in diabetic and non-diabetic patients showed no significant difference in postoperative infection rates and the recurrence of ulcers at the six-month follow-up.8 In patients with hallux interphalangeal joint wounds, however, Armstrong, et al., showed a significantly lower ulcer recurrence rate with surgical treatment (4.8 percent) in comparison to conservative treatment (35 percent) at the six-month follow-up.13
Despite some reported favorable outcomes, there are needs for more randomized clinical trials aimed at procedure specific results and long-term data in order to further elucidate clinical efficacy.
Case Study One: When A Diabetic Patient Has A Hammertoe Deformity
A 45-year-old woman with a past medical history of type 2 diabetes, hypertension and coronary artery disease underwent treatment for hammertoes of her right foot. Despite serial debridements and proper shoes, her digital deformities continued to show no improvement around the pre-ulcerative sites.
The second digit did ulcerate to full thickness but did not involve the joint or the bone. Once the ulceration was healed, I performed proximal interphalangeal joint arthroplasties. The patient showed no signs of mechanical stress on the toes a year after the procedure.
Case Study Two: When A Diabetic Patient Has Distal Preulcerative Lesions
A 60-year-old woman with a past medical history of type 1 diabetes, peripheral neuropathy and distal bypass received treatment for recurrent callus formation at the distal end of the toes of her right foot. She developed this contracture following a traumatic incident to her anterior and lateral leg several years ago.
In addition to quarterly visits for palliative foot care, she received ankle foot orthoses and custom-made shoes with inserts. Despite the conservative efforts, the distal pre-ulcerative sites showed no significant improvement.
I performed prophylactic surgery to correct the rigid deformity. One year after the procedure, the patient continues to wear her accommodative shoes and does not show any signs of skin irritation at the distal ends of the digits.
Prophylactic foot surgery is a relatively new concept that has received greater attention in the last 10 years. In regard to this type of surgery, our goals are reducing mechanical stress on bony areas and preventing ulceration. For each patient, one must weigh the risks and benefits before rendering any invasive treatment.
A clearer understanding of risk factors associated with diabetes has led to several classification systems that may provide the foundation for clinical guidelines and future research. Several studies have shown promising results that prophylactic foot surgery may be safe and effective in preventing recurrent foot ulcerations.
Dr. Baek is in private practice at Laurel Lake Foot and Ankle Center in Laurel, Md. Dr. Baek is an Associate of the American College of Foot and Ankle Surgeons, and is a member of the American Podiatric Medical Association.