Are Ankle Implants Worth Another Look?

Start Page: 46

A Few Thoughts About Ankle Fusion Limitations

Keep in mind that ankle fusions are not without their limitations. The advantages of ankle arthrodesis are limited to pain reduction, stable fixation, an increase in stable ambulation and reduction of severe deformity. However, there are also several reports that described both short- and long-term problems with ankle fusions.2

The common problems described with ankle fusions are: the eventual development of subtalar and metatarsal degenerative joint disease; pain with walking or standing; the need for ambulatory aids; and the need for permanent shoe modifications.

Although the short-term results and complication rates of ankle fusions have been markedly improved by modern techniques of limited periosteal stripping, rigid internal fixation and meticulous attention to alignment/position, the long-term effects of these improved approaches are still unknown.

Several orthopedic surgeons believe the rates of problems related to arthrodesis are unacceptably high and have continued to search for a workable ankle arthroplasty for selected circumstances.

By Mark H. Feldman, MS, DPM, and John Grady, DPM

Yes, Mark H. Feldman, MS, DPM, cites technical advances in the devices and promising results from studies.

Diligent study of normal ankle biomechanics and review of previous implant failures has led to the development of a new generation of total ankle replacement (TAR) implants. The newer implants provide a better means of dissipating the rotational forces at the joint surface by using a meniscus-like bearing between the tibial and talar components, while maintaining the integrity and stability of the joint.1-4
This improvement, coupled with improved cementless fixation, has led to prosthesis designs that allow for more anatomic ankle motion with decreased rates of implant failure.5
A strong understanding of ankle joint biomechanics plays a pivotal role in the design and function of total ankle replacements. Motion and stability of the ankle joint are essential for normal function during gait. The ankle has two degrees of motion and three degrees of stability.6 The two degrees of ankle motion are plantar dorsiflexion and internal-external (axial) rotation.7-11 An inversion-eversion component is also apparent, but Lundberg has described the greater portion of this motion as being associated with the subtalar joint.12
The normal ankle joint is stable and constrained from significant motion in three degrees: anterior-posterior, medial-lateral and inversion-eversion. This is accomplished by intrinsic and extrinsic factors. Both the anterior-posterior and inversion-eversion motions of the ankle are constrained by extrinsic ligaments about the ankle. Medial-lateral movement depends upon the intrinsic support of the ankle mortise itself by the medial and lateral malleolus.
Ankle implant devices must take into consideration the above factors of motion and stability in order to provide near-anatomic motion around the joint. Previous devices did not completely allow for the important rotational (axial) forces and failed to totally consider, and design for, the intrinsic and extrinsic anatomic stability of the ankle mortise.
Currently, there are 11 ankle joint prostheses in use around the world. These include the Agility Ankle (DePuy), STAR, Beuchel-Pappas (Endotec), Salto, Alpha OSG, AES, Albatros, Hintermann, Ramses and a ceramic design used in Japan. The Eska ankle is implanted from the lateral side after an osteotomy of the fibula and reflecting it posteriorly. The implant that I’ve had the most experience with is the Beuchel-Pappas implant, which has been used by surgeons in Europe for over 15 years. The implant has been undergoing FDA clinical investigational trials in the United States since 1998.

image description image description

Post new comment

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

Enter the characters shown in the image.